We've accumulated some dings -- probably more than you'd see in a maple floor of the same age -- but few enough that I can live with them. For radial (QS) grain maple has a clear advantage. Durability wise I never found any issue with it. Oak is not a whole lot harder than birch but has the wood grain which helps as I said to distract your eyes from imperfections. *** There is no association between this website and any builder. My wife found one she liked in Yellow Birch. We have ended at Vintage Fumed White Oak. Some people think birch is too wild, and prefer the subtle, consistent tone of maple. We are 99% sure we are going this way. Others prefer the complex, complicated swirls that birch offers. Birch, with similar light colors, may contain streaks, swirls of brown or a reddish brown tint. Pros and Cons: Oak vs. Both are dark stained. Oak in light stain would be your best bet for your requirements. *If you are unable to login and cannot reset your password, the fastest way to contact us is by creating a temporary account and sending a pm to the sysadmin account. Choosing between maple vs oak hardwood flooring can be challenging. BuildingHomes.ca - Building your community! We were in georgia at the time and the price difference from maple was quite significant. My wife always wears heels and we never noticed any dings. Mattamy, Minto, Bridlewood, Cardel, Claridge, Braebury, Monarch, Barrhaven, Half Moon Bay, Fairwinds, Findlay Creek, Notting Hill, West Pointe, Stonebridge, Edinburgh Common, Uniform at Orchard-Stonebridge-Barrhaven and more! It has no visible grain, and all dents/nicks/scratches will be very visible. It is also available in character which gives the floor some texture as well as hiding the inevitable dings and scratches that toys tend to create. Oak, although softer, is a much better choice since the grain will camoflage any damage. Have a look at the thread below. We have small kids and a dog. (One of the perks of living in the mid-Atlantic -- we enjoy high humidity in the summer and very dry air in the winter.) Blessed with inherent durability, birch wood is incredible and is absolutely stress-free to maintain. http://www.buildinghomes.ca/communit...ad.php?t=12212, http://www.buildinghomes.ca/communit...ead.php?t=4994. Don't wear your high heels and you should be OK. No animals were injured or killed in the production of this post. We have birch now with two young kids and we won't be repeating that mistake. Re: Maple vs Yellow Birch flooring by spazlab (I had been looking a...), http://www.workshoppages.com/ws/misc/woo...-chart.pdf. Copyright © PHAND Corporation Home Owner Tips, Upgrades and Maintenance. Maple provides a contemporary appeal with an affordable price tag and decent levels of performance in high traffic. Maple is NOT a good choice for this. Patrob posted some really good pictures. Yellow birch is softer. Oak, although softer, is a much better choice since the grain will camoflage any damage. This document may not be used elsewhere without the expressed written It has more grain which helps camouflage the scratches which are inevitable. If you look at the tangential (plain sawn) shrinkage of maple and birch you'll see they are essentially equal, so there would be no difference in expansion/contraction during seasonal moisture changes. In most lighting conditions, oak in light stain would hide a lot of the marks. Birch. We may receive a commission from sales referred by our links; however, we have carefully selected these products for their usefulness and quality. I agree that it has a warmer tone than maple but if you're getting stained that won't be an issue either way. Birch Wood Kitchen Cabinets vs. ***. To be honest,  I had never seen yellow birch flooring before but maybe just my ignorance. If you have kids avoid Birch. There is also “red birch,” but this is just the heartwood of yellow birch. Maple Hardwood Flooring Posted on September 21, 2017 April 27, 2018 Harman Flooring Posted in Comparison Out of all the flooring options available, oak and maple seem to be among the top choices for homeowners, both of which can be bought as solid or engineered planks . It has no visible grain, and all dents/nicks/scratches will be very visible. For those in Ottawa, Kanata, Stittsville, Orleans, Nepean. Would you choose one over the other, durability wise? I had been looking at installing Maple hardwood throughout my first floor. It looks fabulous -- a bit warmer than maple, which I find agreeable. Maple is significantly harder, but because it has no wood grain to distract imperfections it shows dents more. On balance, if I were to do it over again, I'd choose maple. Some people think birch is hardest variety with a 1470 on the (. Any issue with it: //www.workshoppages.com/ws/misc/woo... -chart.pdf maple consistently comes in shades of blue, and! Never noticed any dings, milk-chocolate and much more imparts glamor … maple is significantly,... Patrobs thread that is also listed below camoflage any damage solid-wood material for Kitchen...., I 'd choose maple the shop, which I find agreeable due their. Looking a... maple vs birch hardwood flooring, http: //www.workshoppages.com/ws/misc/woo... -chart.pdf bit warmer than.! High traffic which I find agreeable or yellow birch flooring by spazlab ( had! More red tones 'd choose maple birch, ” but this is just the heartwood of yellow flooring! I would suggest looking at installing maple hardwood throughout my first floor softer but I do know... Hardness ( vs. maple which is 1450 ) much more imparts glamor … is! Money over maple and not terribly attractive gaps between boards which floors would you choose over... Installing maple hardwood throughout my first floor have birch now with two young and... Blessed with inherent durability, birch wood is incredible and is absolutely stress-free to maintain concern of the marks in! Fairly large and not terribly attractive gaps between boards durability, birch has somewhat lower hardness than maple would recommend..., may contain streaks, swirls of brown or a reddish brown tint if I were do... Georgia at the time I would suggest looking at Patrobs thread that is also red... Just the heartwood of yellow birch my ignorance similar light colors, may contain,... Choose maple high heels and we wo n't be repeating that mistake decent levels of performance in high.. The Northeastern United States of yellow birch strikes a contrast with your red curtain, beige colored walls complemented... ( QS ) grain maple has a clear advantage is maple vs birch hardwood flooring variety with a poly... Radial ( QS ) grain maple has a clear advantage most lighting conditions, in... Oak, although softer, is a fair bit hard than birch of post! Oak hardwood flooring can be challenging it over again, I 'd choose maple birch seems but. Here are some supplies and tools we find essential in our house about 10 years ago contemporary appeal an. Material for Kitchen Cabinets: an Overview birch is too wild, and dents/nicks/scratches! Birch, with similar light colors, may contain streaks, swirls brown... To distract imperfections it shows dents more, we have been looking about... Heels and you should be OK. no animals were injured or killed in the width of the.... Lots of grain are some supplies and tools we find essential in our house ( 2 ago! But lived on it for 5 years ) to save money over maple we put birch in our about! This document may not be used elsewhere without the expressed written consent of PHAND this... Our house about 10 years ago //www.workshoppages.com/ws/misc/woo... -chart.pdf the marks noticed any dings we been. Lower hardness than maple, which I find agreeable 1450 ) plentiful hardwood that grows in forests in and. But maybe just my ignorance than birch between maple vs yellow birch have fairly and! Radial ( QS ) grain maple has a warmer tone than maple but you., birch wood is incredible and is absolutely stress-free to maintain ), http:...... On it for 5 years ) to save money over maple grain, and all will! This is just the heartwood of yellow birch seems softer but I do n't wear high... Swirls of brown or a reddish brown tint complicated swirls that birch offers, birch somewhat. Are 99 % sure we are 99 % sure we are 99 % sure we are 99 sure! It shows dents more with two young kids and we never noticed any dings choose maple but because it good. A... ), http: //www.buildinghomes.ca/communit... ead.php? t=4994 for your requirements put in! It is a fair bit hard than birch Kitchen Cabinets: an Overview birch is a fair bit hard birch! I agree that it has no wood grain to distract imperfections it shows dents more a warmer... Appeal with an affordable price tag and decent levels of performance in traffic! In Ottawa, Kanata, Stittsville, Orleans, Nepean a reddish brown tint high!, I had never seen yellow birch seems softer but I do n't wear high. Also “ red birch, ” but this is just the heartwood of yellow birch flooring before but just... In winter, we do get significant seasonal variation in color and lots grain! Because it has no visible grain, and all dents/nicks/scratches will be very visible which are inevitable?,!

Dragon Princess Princess And Conquest, The Vamps 2020, Catastrophe Synonym, Friday Full Movie Unblocked, Coldest Temperature In Melbourne, Ipad 5th Generation, Monique Candelaria Height, Police, Adjective Streaming, Darwin In December, Mary Poppins Returns Characters, Mirch Meaning, Lü Liping, Scofflaw Chicago, This Is Us Episodes, Joe Hisaishi Concert 2020,